Five Critical Insurance Mistakes Nonprofits Must Avoid 

Discover the top five insurance mistakes nonprofits often make—and how to avoid them. Learn how the right policies can protect your people, mission, and operations with insights from Lamb Insurance Services.

June 24, 2025 / Dana Pandorf
nonprofit board discussing insurance and business needs

Nonprofit and human service organizations operate in complex environments with unique risks and liabilities. Despite their charitable status or modest size, they are not immune to financial or reputational damage. Many often face the same exposures as for-profit businesses, from property damage and cyber threats to employment-related disputes and board-level decisions.  

Although general liability insurance is crucial for covering third-party bodily injury, property damage, and specific personal injury claims (such as libel or slander), it does not safeguard against employment lawsuits, abuse claims, professional negligence, or errors in management decisions.  

Protect your assets, reputation, and mission by avoiding these five common insurance mistakes in today’s current environment. 

 

Assuming General Liability Covers Abuse Claims

Many nonprofits mistakenly believe their general liability or Directors & Officers (D&O) policy covers abuse. Most often, it doesn’t. Nonprofits serving children, seniors, or other vulnerable populations must possess adequate coverage for sexual abuse or molestation claims. Many believe that a standard general liability or directors and officers (D&O) policy will cover such claims; however, a nonprofit’s insurance strategy should always include a separate policy designed to protect organizations from claims arising from incidents of sexual misconduct, molestation, or physical abuse by employees, volunteers, or even client-on-client incidents. 

 

Overlooking Cyber Threats Due to Budget or Size

In today’s digital age, cyber liability insurance coverage is no longer optional for nonprofits. Thinking you’re too small to target is risky. Hackers have learned that smaller nonprofit organizations often have weaker security measures in place, making your organization vulnerable. Whether you’re managing donor databases, client records or internal systems, your organization is a target for cybercriminals. Cyberattacks can halt operations, compromise donor trust, drain financial resources and expose your board to litigation. Cyber liability insurance provides the financial and legal support necessary to respond effectively. 

 

Failing to Properly Insure Volunteers

Failing to secure adequate insurance coverage for volunteers is a common mistake that can expose nonprofits to significant financial and legal risks. While some states have limited liability protections for volunteers, relying solely on these protections or failing to implement appropriate risk management strategies can leave nonprofits vulnerable to lawsuits and financial damages. Nonprofit and human service organizations should secure coverage designed to cover the medical expenses and other costs associated with volunteer injuries and protect against lawsuits arising from mistakes or oversights by the organization or its volunteers. Specific coverage, like a volunteer accident or liability policy, can help bridge this gap. 

 

Leaving Board Members Personally Exposed

Without D&O insurance, board members and the executive leadership team could be personally liable for decisions made on behalf of the organization. Allegations of mismanagement, conflict of interest, or breach of fiduciary duty can result in costly litigation, putting both the organization and its leaders at risk without D&O protection.   

 

Being Unprepared for Disasters and Operational Interruptions

Like any other business or organization, nonprofits are indeed vulnerable to damage and losses from natural disasters and other events. In today’s world, disaster insurance coverage is indispensable for nonprofits, serving to safeguard their assets, guarantee continuous mission delivery, uphold financial stability, and meet the expectations of their donors. Without adequate preparation, a disaster carries the potential for service interruption, significant financial strain, and reputational harm. Insurance offers a crucial financial safety net, enabling nonprofits to recover and respond to crises more effectively. 

 

Bonus Tip – Ignoring Shifts in Funding and Legal Risk

Recent shifts in public policy and funding have left so many nonprofit and human service organizations vulnerable. Staffing cuts, government/grant reductions, and increased scrutiny over fiduciary performance have heightened exposure to employment practices and contract-related claims. Now is the time to reassess your Errors & Omissions (E&O) and Employment Practices Liability Insurance (EPLI) coverage needs with an experienced broker who understands nonprofit operations. 

 

As the nation’s leading insurance brokerage dedicated exclusively to insuring nonprofit and human service organizations, Lamb Insurance Services is committed to helping you navigate risk and secure the necessary coverage you need so you can focus on what matters most: serving your community.  

Let's talk

You can count on LAMB to do the right thing in support of your mission.